Polish court rules some EU laws and articles incompatible with country’s constitution.

Poland’s legal standoff with the EU has reached breaking point after its highest court ruled that some EU laws and articles of the European Treaties are incompatible with the Polish constitution.

In a ruling on Thursday the constitutional court in Warsaw said Poland’s EU accession in 2004 had not ended national sovereignty over its affairs, and that the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) was not the country’s supreme legal authority.

“The primacy of constitutional law over other sources of law results directly from the constitution of the Republic of Poland, ” said Piotr Muller, government spokesman, commenting on the ruling. “Today [once more] this has been clearly confirmed by the constitutional tribunal.”

Thursday’s ruling – backed by 12 members of a constitutional court, with two dissensions – challenges articles one and 19 of the European treaties, referring to the EU’s legal basis and the European Court of Justice (CJEU).

Since taking power in 2015, Poland’s ruling Law and Justice (PiS) party has carried out widespread reform of public media, the public prosecutor service and the judiciary.

It says reform was necessary to remove encrusted crony structures, but critics see a concerted effort to bring all aspects of public life under PiS control.

A series of legal actions by Polish judges and the European Commission has met with a frosty response in Warsaw. In recent months government ministers have challenged the primacy of EU law, a key pillar of the union.

National law

Last July the constitutional court – headed by judges critics say are illegally-appointed government cornies – opened a hearing into the relationship of EU and national law.

Court president Julia Anna Przylebska, a friend of PiS chairman Jaroslaw Kaczynski, postponed a final ruling until after this week’s CJEU verdict.

Anticipating a drastic reaction from Warsaw, the Luxembourg-based CJEU warned Poland on Wednesday that its reforms had given “rise to reasonable doubt in the minds of individuals as to the independence and impartiality” of judges and courts.

Poland disputes the right of EU courts to intervene in its domestic affairs, in particular its judiciary, and has ignored a number of recent rulings. The CJEU insisted on Wednesday its interventions were permissible, in defence of EU law and its guarantee of independent and impartial courts in member states.

“A member state’s reliance on rules of national law, even of a constitutional order, cannot be allowed to undermine the unity and effectiveness of EU law,” the Luxembourg court added.

Ahead of Thursday’s ruling, Poland’s human rights commissioner warned against conflict with the EU, saying it plunges Poland into crisis and lower legal protection standards.

Emergency funds

On Tuesday prime minister Mateusz Morawiecki, who requested the constitutional court hearing, dismissed talk of Poland’s EU departure – or “Polexit”– as “fake news”.

In Brussels, EU officials said that shattering the “taboo” over EU law primacy raised questions about Poland’s future EU membership and its share of pandemic emergency funds.

“We cannot transfer billions to a member state without being able to legally ensure that the money reaches those for whom it is intended,” said Daniel Freund, a German MEP who sits on the EU parliament’s budget committee.

The Irish Times

The Irish Times online. Latest news including sport, analysis, business, weather and more from the definitive brand of quality news in Ireland.

https://www.irishtimes.com/

Police give update on deadly shooting at Boise mall.

Police give update on deadly shooting at Boise mall.

At least two people were killed and four were injured in a shooting at a mall in Boise, Idaho, police officials said Monday. A suspect is in custody. CBSN is CBS News’ 24/7 digital streaming news service featuring live, anchored coverage available...

Report says members of Congress, White House officials met with organizers of January 6th protest.

Report says members of Congress, White House officials met with organizers of January 6th protest.

A new report from Rolling Stone says the organizers of the January 6th rally had dozens of planning meetings with members of Congress and White House officials. CBS News senior investigative correspondent Catherine Herridge joined CBSN's "Red and ...

Mitt Romney: Democrats 'new tax scheme' a big mistake.

Mitt Romney: Democrats 'new tax scheme' a big mistake.

Utah Republican discusses the unintended consequences of the president's tax plan on 'Special Report' #FoxNews Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News Channel Live: FOX News Channel (FNC) is a 24-hour all-encompassing news...

Internal Documents Feveal Facebook Knew Of Platform’s Harms.

Internal Documents Feveal Facebook Knew Of Platform’s Harms.

Newly revealed documents show that Facebook has been studying the social harms that plague its platform for years. Researchers warned that the company’s “core mechanisms” allow potentially dangerous and harmful content to flourish. Zuckerberg slam...

New Details In Fatal Shooting On ‘Rust’ Movie Set

New Details In Fatal Shooting On ‘Rust’ Movie Set

A search warrant released overnight reveals what happened before and after the gunfire. According to the warrant, Alec Baldwin was given a prop gun declared safe for use by assistant director Dave Halls. Halls told investigators he didn’t know liv...

CEO Mark Zuckerberg responds to the massive Facebook document dump.

CEO Mark Zuckerberg responds to the massive Facebook document dump.

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg kicked off a quarterly earnings call by addressing the latest wave of coverage based on a trove of leaked internal documents. #CNN #News