Moscow moves from justifying GULAG to glorifying it.

Now that Russian officials are proposing to use prison labor for economic projects, a Novosti journalist has countered charges that this constitutes the restoration of Stalin’s GULAG by arguing that many of the camps at that time had far better living conditions than many now assume.

Indeed, Viktoriya Nikiforova says, Russians should not accept the widespread myths about Stalin’s camps that have been spread about by Russophobes inside Russia and abroad but rather consider the conditions inside and outside the camps at the time (see ria.ru and newizv.ru).

“The initiative of the Federal Penal System to use the labor of incarcerated citizens at construction sides has elicited a predictable outpouring of hatred from the side of ‘democratic society.’ This in their view will be a new GULAG or even worse.” Before accepting that description, Russians should examine the facts about the camps in Stalin’s time.

Further reading: Putin restores the GULAG by legalizing slave labor of convicts

“The ‘Archipelago,’ in spite of the myths we have been given was broad and varied,” Nikiforova says. “There were camps with openly horrific conditions but there were also those with as it was called ‘model’ arrangements” given the time and place in which they were operational.

'Third degree interrogation' from "Drawings from the GULAG" by Danzig Baldaev, a former NKVD guard

‘Third degree interrogation’ from “Drawings from the GULAG” by Danzig Baldaev, a former NKVD guard

“One must not forget the general level of life in Soviet Russia after the Civil War. For intellectuals in the capital, for former merchants, and for kulaks, camp conditions we re often a nightmare. But for the poor peasant, for the urban lumpen and for homeless children, people who literally had starved their whole lives, the labor camp offered three meals a day, warm housing, and some medical help.”

Further reading: The story of Father Ivan Kypriyan and his children who froze to death in a soviet gulag

Indeed, the state news agency journalist says, “this was a more or less normal life in comparison with the most difficult circumstances which the poor at that time experienced. An important part of this was labor activity.” It provides inmates with training that allowed them in the future to rise economically. The camps thus were “a social lift.”

Guards disposing of corpses of executed GULAG prisoners in a frozen river by Danzig Baldaev, a former NKVD guard

“Drowning frozen corpses of GULAG prisoners in a frozen Siberian river” by Danzig Baldaev, a former NKVD guard

And she continues, “the main means of successful socialization after the term of punishment became the workers’ specialization. This was a real ‘pathway in life.’ It allowed the former criminal element to join the ranks of law-abiding citizens.” Yes, there were excesses but as a rule, “the country had to be concerned about its citizens.”

Further reading: They broke the GULAG: How Ukrainians overcame the Soviet repressive machine

At the very least, Nikiforova says, the Soviet system was better than the racially based arrangements in the United States. “In no case” should Russians want to copy what the Americans are doing in their penal system. But to no one’s surprise, many Russians who are better informed than Nikiforova are outraged by her remarks.

A false confession under torture: "I’m… an English, French, American, Japanese, Italian, German and maybe some other spy as well…" ("Drawings from the GULAG" by Danzig Baldaev, a former NKVD guard)

A false confession under torture: “I’m… an English, French, American, Japanese, Italian, German and maybe some other spy as well…” (“Drawings from the GULAG” by Danzig Baldaev, a former NKVD guard)

Publicist Nikolay Podosokorsky says that he isn’t shocked because not long ago, Mariya Butina of the Social Chamber compared the prison where Russian opposition figure Alexei Navalny is confined to a Pioneer children camp. Nikiforova’s words are simply the logical next step in that chain.

Further reading: GULAG was not something far away in Siberia: it was all around, even in Moscow

Journalist Kirill Shulika isn’t surprised either. What the Novosti writer is saying now reflects what many in the Russian political elite think. And it is very likely, the journalist says, that they will soon be saying what she has said as if it were a truth that must not be questioned.

SELECTION OF SEX SLAVES FROM NEW ARRIVALS OUT OF THE "ENEMIES OF THE PEOPLE" (OR THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS) BY GULAG BOSSES: Women-"enemies of the people" were inspected by the job assignment commission in the nude. Liked women were assigned to the camp household duties where they became sex slaves. If they refused, they were assigned to fell trees and other such hard physical labor or were incarcerated in solitary confinement cells for "delinquency" and starved there. ("Drawings from the GULAG" by Danzig Baldaev, a former guard)

SELECTION OF SEX SLAVES FROM NEW ARRIVALS OUT OF THE “ENEMIES OF THE PEOPLE” (OR THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS) BY GULAG BOSSES: Women-“enemies of the people” were inspected by the job assignment commission in the nude. Liked women were assigned to the camp household duties where they became sex slaves. If they refused, they were assigned to fell trees and other such hard physical labor or were incarcerated in solitary confinement cells for “delinquency” and starved there. (“Drawings from the GULAG” by Danzig Baldaev, a former guard)

Scholar Vera Afanasyeva says that what is especially worrisome is that NIkiforova’s words not only are going to be realized but suggest the direction in which the Putin regime is headed, toward the restoration of the GULAG system with all the real horrors it featured.

Further reading: A new GULAG is emerging just as Stalin’s did slowly and insidiously, Gudkov warns

But Abbas Gallyamov, a former Putin speechwriter, argues that the Nikiforova text is a sign of something else, the continuing degradation of the Putin regime. Its leaders should have chosen someone more professional to make this argument especially in the run-up to the Duma elections.

Putting out the message right now, Gallyamov says, that “People, a GULAG is waiting for you” and that it will be organized in such a way that “it will seem a paradise to you” is hardly going to attract Russian voters as even the most benighted denizen of the Kremlin should have recognized.

Read More:

Ukraine needs independent journalism. And we need you. Join our community on Patreon and help us better connect Ukraine to the world. We’ll use your contribution to attract new authors, upgrade our website, and optimize its SEO. And plus, the International Renaissance Foundation will double the money that our patrons will collect by 14 June -- so your contribution and impact will be multiplied! For as little as the cost of one cup of coffee a month, you can help build bridges between Ukraine and the rest of the world, plus become a co-creator and vote for topics we should cover next. Become a patron or see other ways to support. Become a Patron!

Related

Tags: , , ,

Euromaidan Press

News and Opinion from Ukraine and Europe on Military and Political Developments.

http://euromaidanpress.com/

Related news
COVID-19 Cases Hit New Highs In Russia

COVID-19 Cases Hit New Highs In Russia

Russia reported another sharp rise in fresh COVID-19 cases on June 13, a day after the mayor of Moscow told residents of the Russian capital to say home from work next week to curb the spread of the virus.

Radio Free Europe

Judge Jeanine reacts to 'absurd' Time Magazine cover featuring Biden.

Judge Jeanine reacts to 'absurd' Time Magazine cover featuring Biden.

Fox News host wonders if Joe Biden is 'up to the task' to take on Vladimir Putin. #FoxNews #Hannity Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News Channel Live: FOX News Channel (FNC) is a 24-hour all-encompassing news service de...

G-7 Summit Aims to Build Back Better, Greener

G-7 Summit Aims to Build Back Better, Greener

World’s richest democracies meet in Cornwall, England, with bold ambitions to lead the world out of the pandemic

NBC Nightly News Broadcast (Full) - June 11th, 2021.

NBC Nightly News Broadcast (Full) - June 11th, 2021.

An NBC News exclusive interview with Russian President Vladimir Putin, President Biden meets with G7 leaders, and Johnson & Johnson told to destroy 60 million vaccine doses. Watch “NBC Nightly News With Lester Holt” at 6:30 p.m. ET / 5:30 p.m. CT ...

Rep. Jackie Speier: Trump-era DOJ tried to ‘violate the Constitution’

Rep. Jackie Speier: Trump-era DOJ tried to ‘violate the Constitution’

Congresswoman Jackie Speier, D-Calif., discusses reports that the Trump Justice Department targeted Democratic colleagues. ABC News Live Prime, Weekdays at 7EST & 9EST WATCH the ABC News Live Stream Here: SUBSCRIBE to ABC NEWS: Watch More on LIKE ...

The Rundown: Top headlines today: June 11, 2021

The Rundown: Top headlines today: June 11, 2021

Stay up to date on the developing stories making headlines. ABC News Live Prime, Weekdays at 7EST & 9EST WATCH the ABC News Live Stream Here: SUBSCRIBE to ABC NEWS: Watch More on LIKE ABC News on FACEBOOK FOLLOW ABC News on TWITTER:

National Treasure: Danny Glover’s life, career and activism.

National Treasure: Danny Glover’s life, career and activism.

ABC News’ Linsey Davis sits down with Danny Glover to discuss what drives his activism -- and what he sees as his most meaningful role. ABC News Live Prime, Weekdays at 7EST & 9EST WATCH the ABC News Live Stream Here: SUBSCRIBE to ABC NEWS: Watch ...