Activists continue fight to save unique Ukrainian mountain ridge from green energy project.

Editor’s Note

Ukrainian ecological activists have been fighting for four years to protect the unique Borzhava ridge, one of the most beautiful places in the Carpathians, from the construction of a huge wind power plant. The case perfectly reflects the state of the current Ukrainian legal system and institutions. Still rather slow, over-bureaucratic, misused when not controlled by the public but already transparent and with the rule of law gradually ousting old corrupt practices.

The case also reveals that green energy is no panacea when investors try to use its popularity and green tariffs to destroy the most valuable of natural places. It also reveals what the further needs of Ukrainian reform in environmental protection are in order to underpin what has already been successfully completed.

Ecology was never a priority in the Soviet Union or post-Soviet Ukraine, where profit has always been the ultimate goal, initially for the communist party and later for private companies. Ecological norms, although nominally in existence, could be easily violated via corruption.

Things have changed since the entering into force of the new Law on the Strategical Estimation of the Impact on Environment, which introduced a transparent procedure of ecological monitoring at the end of 2017. Each new construction project is required to pass it.

Other reforms empowering transparency and public control over government also help, including the huge work done towards the creation and implementation of the internationally recognized Emerald Network of nature reserves in Ukraine.

What is Borzhava ridge

The Borzhava ridge is one of the most picturesque places in the Ukrainian Carpathians. The ridge is about 50 kilometers long. It is the longest mountain meadow in the Zakarpattia region and can safely claim the title of being the most picturesque. The surface of the mountains is grassy, covered with blueberries, in some places with cowberries.

The flora and fauna on the ridge include dozens of Red Book species of plants and animals. Importantly, international migration routes of birds pass over the ridge. It is included in the Emerald Network, which is a network of Areas of Special Conservation Interest to conserve wild flora and fauna in Europe and North Africa.

The Emerald Network was established in 1989 by the Council of Europe according to the Berne Convention on the Conservation of European Wildlife and Natural Habitats signed by European states including Ukraine. Thus the Borzhava ridge is recognized as important for environmental conservation not only for Ukraine but for the whole of Europe.

Areas of the Emerald Network. Ukraine is concluding the establishment of its Emerland Network this year according to the Association Agreement with the EU. The relevant law is now under consideration in the Ukrainian parliament Source: emerald.net.ua

Apart from ecology, the ridge is also a picturesque tourist site. After the occupation of Crimea by Russia, Borzhava ridge became the most popular site for gliders. It is also the third most popular hiker and bicycle route, after the highest Chornohora and Gorgany ridges.

Sustainable energy populism and activist’s

Since 2017 several Ukrainian NGOs have been fighting against the proposed wind power plant consisting of 34 windmills on the ridge. The construction would not only destroy valuable species on the ridge and prevent the migration of birds but also destroy the landscape of this beautiful mountain chain.

“The construction of windmills is large-scale construction work. To build a 200-meter-high windmill on a mountain meadow, it is necessary to build roads that will bring construction equipment, in fact, cut off the top of the ridge to lay rails, which will drive a derrick that will lift the generating plant. Power grids will be laid underground, so deep trenches will have to be dug, and all this earth will fall down. Meadow will be destroyed, as well as rare species and habitats that are included in Resolution 4 of the Bern Convention, protected in Europe,” explains the head of the Ukrainian Environmental Protection Group Oleksiy Vasyliuk.

https://i0.wp.com/zakarpattya.net.ua/postimages/news/2018/3/66.jpg?resize=960%2C540&ssl=1

This is how Borzhava meadow would look like with windmills.

This case is also an example of ecological populism . Recently, Ukraine has encountered a boom in green energy power plants that enjoy high green tariffs for the state. To build windmills at this high altitude would be super-profitable. And it was presented as allegedly being a good ecological thing that contributes to sustainable energy production. In fact scientists who prepared documentation on the estimation of the ecological impact of construction lied straightforwardly in their conclusions for the sake of investors.

“ In the report, they investigate whether the construction and operation of windmills on the Borzhava ridge will harm otters which have never been there. At the same time regarding the Red Book Alpine woodpeckers, over whose heads it is proposed to place wind turbines, pseudo-scientists suggest simply catching and relocating them to other places. They propose builders (!) to catch Red Book animals. These allegedly experts also provided winter photos of the area where the windmills are planned to be located, and wrote that no types of flora and fauna protected by law were found there, ” says ecologist Kateryna Polianska.

In old times, this kind of simulation of ecological assessment could easily work. However, since the end of 2017, the new law establishes proper procedures in assessing the ecological impact of new construction which includes full transparency, public hearing of the assessment and the opportunity for everyone to question it. This procedure allowed ecologists to criticize the fake and unprofessional assessment that was allowing construction. After their comments and critique were not taken into consideration, they sued the company which planned to construct windmills and won in March 2020. The assessment of ecological impact was recognized as invalid by the local court. The company, however, won an appeal and the legal battle continued in the Supreme Court.

Nonetheless, no construction of big objects is possible without impact assessment being publicly presented and recognized – a reliable safeguard against ecological harm which at the very least helps activists to win time.

Pressure from international organizations are another working tool used by activists

At the same time “scientists did not expect that the state would be able to protect the charm of the Ukrainian Carpathians and filed a complaint to the Bern Convention. The Permanent Committee of the Bern Convention appealed to Ukraine to stop any dangerous construction on the ridge ,” writes ecologist Tetiana Shamina, claiming that the final court decision can still come in favor of the company.

International law is another mechanism that helps to save nature in Ukraine, while the state is fulfilling its functions of protection only under pressure — from civil society or international institutions.

“It is important to understand that the territories of the Emerald Network were created at European level. At national level, the state is often unable to adequately regulate the system of protected areas. However, if there are any threats to the territories of the Emerald Network, the Berne Convention always reacts and encourages the state to react, because protecting these territories is an international obligation of Ukraine, ” explained Igor Hrynyk, a biologist at the Ukrainian Environmental Protection Group.

Borzahva ridge in Ukrainian Carpathians. Source: ua.igotoworld.com

New threat to Borzhava ridge comes from President himself

The conclusion of the Permanent Committee of the Berne Convention is extremely important to prevent the construction of windmills as well as a new threat – the proposed construction of a ski resort presented by President Zelenskyy himself as a promising investment project for Ukraine, ignoring ecological threats.

This new dangerous idea is now being blocked in two ways: internationally by the decision of the Permanent Committee of the Berne Convention and domestically due to the absence of ecological assessment without which any construction cannot begin. There were no announcements of a transparent strategic environmental assessment of this project yet. Therefore talks about Ski resorts remain only talks so far.

An expert from the Berne Convention will visit Ukraine this year to study the situation regarding the threat to the natural value of the Borzhava Meadow. Borzhava’s issues were considered by the Permanent Committee of the Berne Convention in the winter, and all participants unanimously supported the proposal to conduct an independent on-site examination in 2021. It is now known that according to the decision of the Permanent Committee of the Convention, Ukraine should not start any work on Borzhava until it receives the final conclusions of the committee.

The sad thing is that the president himself popularized this idea, ignoring ecological risks. Activists should constantly monitor the situation so as not to miss any implementation of the idea. This perfectly demonstrates the thesis that rule of law already starts working in Ukraine, but without strong public control the temptation for old permissiveness remains.

Creating a nature reserve in Borzhava would help end any further battles there

Considering the last thesis, it is obvious that new threats will continue to endanger Ukraine’s valuable national assets until such time as the government learns to protect these assets not only under pressure but willingly. Environmentalists are convinced that one of the leading mechanisms that could help save Borzhava and other valuable objects is the creation of nature reserves . However, this procedure in Ukraine is complicated and bureaucratic. For example, two years ago there was an intention to create a landscape reserve called Zelenytsa. However, the local administration refused to approve its creation.

Another attempt took place in early March 2021. Activists are working now to approve the creation of a regional landscape park called Borzhava Meadows. With the consent of land users, it is possible to create a regional landscape park which the defenders of Borzhava very much hope for. In that case, any construction not related to the protection of the area, or any demolition groundwork will be prohibited, explains Tetiana Shamina.

Read also:

Ukraine needs independent journalism. And we need you. Join our community on Patreon and help us better connect Ukraine to the world. We’ll use your contribution to attract new authors, upgrade our website, and optimize its SEO. For as little as the cost of one cup of coffee a month, you can help build bridges between Ukraine and the rest of the world, plus become a co-creator and vote for topics we should cover next. Become a patron or see other ways to support. Become a Patron!

Related

Tags: , , , , ,

Euromaidan Press

News and Opinion from Ukraine and Europe on Military and Political Developments.

http://euromaidanpress.com/

Related news

Five Ukrainian startups that really went global

1. Grammarly, a writing assistant When asked about his life purpose, Grammarly co-founder Dmytro Lider says, “It is the implementation of one’s own values through actions… I focus not on delivering results but on creating and living through ...

Euromaidan Press

Left remains silent on prominent Democrat donor's criminal conviction.

Left remains silent on prominent Democrat donor's criminal conviction.

Ed Buck was convicted in overdose deaths of two black men; Organizer of protests in Ed Buck's case Jasmyne Cannick reacts on 'Fox News Primetime.' #FoxNews #FoxNewsPrimetime Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News Channel ...

Dozens still missing in Germany two weeks after floods - DW News.

Dozens still missing in Germany two weeks after floods - DW News.

Two weeks after the devastating floods in western Germany, the disaster is far from over. People are only slowly working their way through dealing with what the flood has left behind: bulks of mud and piles of rubbish. Dozens of people are still m...

Moment jewel thief swaps £4.2m of diamonds for pebbles in Ocean’s Eleven con

Moment jewel thief swaps £4.2m of diamonds for pebbles in Ocean’s Eleven con

THIS is the moment a 60-year-old jewel thief swapped diamonds worth £4.2million for PEBBLES in an Ocean's Eleven-style con - before blaming her dead sister for the heist. Lulu Lakatos, 60, who has now been convicted of the biggest jewellery shop c...

UK summer temperatures may hit 40C

UK summer temperatures may hit 40C

Meteorologists are warning summer temperatures in the UK may hit 40c. It comes as the government announced it will spend £860m on flood defence schemes to help protect "thousands of homes and businesses". SUBSCRIBE to our YouTube channel for more ...

BREAKING: Record 689,313 people 'pinged' by NHS COVID app.

BREAKING: Record 689,313 people 'pinged' by NHS COVID app.

A record 689,313 people in England and Wales have been 'pinged' by the NHS COVID app - up 11.4% from the previous week. SUBSCRIBE to our YouTube channel for more videos: Follow us on Twitter: Like us on Facebook: Follow us on Instagram: For more c...

Alaska on Tsunami warning after massive 8.2 magnitude earthquake strikes off US coast

Alaska on Tsunami warning after massive 8.2 magnitude earthquake strikes off US coast

A HUGE 8.2 magnitude earthquake has sparked tsunami fears in Alaska and Hawaii. The quake hit the Alaska Peninsula at at 10:15p.m. local time (06:15 UK time) but there were no immediate reports on loss of property or life. The National Tsunami War...