NATO, EU and US advised on how to amend SBU draft law.

NATO, EU and US advised on how to amend SBU draft law

The International Advisory Group (ICG), created by the United States, the European Union and NATO, has published a positive opinion on the latest version of the draft law on the Security Service of Ukraine.

As reported by Censor.NET.

The working group, first of all, stressed general support for the final version of the draft, noting that "this draft law can serve as a solid basis for a fundamental reform of the SBU in accordance with European and Euro-Atlantic principles and best practices."

However, the broad positive conclusion of the ICG contains one remark: Western experts strongly recommend that Ukraine change the current wording of Article 8-2 of the law "On counterintelligence activities" (this law is also being changed within the framework of the reform), which allows it to be used in court as evidence in criminal cases. data collected by the SBU counterintelligence during covert surveillance measures.

"The use of counterintelligence data in court creates a number of serious challenges ... In general, the threshold and legal requirements for the collection of evidence in a criminal case for use in court are higher, given a very different task: evidence is collected against a person, and intelligence data is collected for the state. is that counterintelligence data for use in court is often classified, and this affects the human right to a fair trial, since the defendants and their lawyers may not have access to such data in order to properly prepare the line of defence, "- said in particular, in the recommendations of the ICG.

International experts note that if the draft is adopted in its current form, there is "concern about the risk of misuse of counterintelligence information for political and corruption purposes." "The ICG recommends that the draft law clearly limit the use of such materials only for serious criminal offences and clearly spell out the procedure for using intelligence information as evidence in a trial," the analysis provided by Ukraine's partners says.

Read more: Kuleba: We will talk with ambassadors of Germany, France to understand how their proposal on Russia relates to sanctions policy, role of Normandy format mediators

However, on all other positions, the ICG gave positive feedback, supporting the key proposed changes.

In particular, explanations from experts from NATO, the EU and the United States answer questions about why it is important to completely deprive the SBU of the function of pre-trial investigation, whether it is worth keeping the SBU's right to conduct investigations related to national security, why the SBU should not engage in economic crimes, smuggling or corruption, and also why it is advisable to reduce the staff of the SBU during the unprecedented hybrid war of the Russian Federation against Ukraine.

Censor.Net

Ukrainian News site. We find breaking news, multimedia, reviews & opinion on Kiev, business, sports & more at Censor.net.

https://censor.net/en

Related news
Obama under fire for planning 'super spreader' party with up to 700 people.

Obama under fire for planning 'super spreader' party with up to 700 people.

'The Five' reacts to liberal hypocrisy surrounding COVID-19. #FoxNews #TheFive Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News Channel Live: FOX News Channel (FNC) is a 24-hour all-encompassing news service delivering breaking new...

Sen. Lindsey Graham says he has tested positive for COVID-19

Sen. Lindsey Graham says he has tested positive for COVID-19

Meanwhile, President Joe Biden faces challenges with shifting scientific consensus on the virus.

Shona Community Granted Kenyan Citizenship

Shona Community Granted Kenyan Citizenship

Citizenship opens educational and economic doors for Shona

NHS app to ping fewer people to isolate

NHS app to ping fewer people to isolate

The NHS app is going to be changed so that close contacts of a positive case will only be made to isolate if that contact was in the last two days. Sky's Paul Kelso reports. SUBSCRIBE to our YouTube channel for more videos: Follow us on Twitter: L...

Dr. Anthony Fauci warns things will get worse amid delta variant surge

Dr. Anthony Fauci warns things will get worse amid delta variant surge

The U.S. is seeing more than 100,000 new cases a day for the first time since February.

Student debt holding Americans back from wealth, even high-earning millennials.

Student debt holding Americans back from wealth, even high-earning millennials.

A recent study revealed many so-called “HENRYs,” or “high earners not rich yet” feel like they’re living paycheck to paycheck.