European Parliament expected to strip Catalan ex-president of immunity.

The European Parliament is expected to withdraw the immunity of former Catalan president Carles Puigdemont and two fellow MEPs next week, allowing proceedings to extradite them to Spain to resume.

Last month, the parliament’s committee on legal affairs voted to recommend that the immunity of Puigdemont and his colleagues, Antoni Comín and Clara Ponsatí, be lifted. Although that decision is not binding, it is expected to lead to the waiver being approved when the chamber votes on Monday.

This is the latest episode in a complex and drawn-out legal wrangle, which began after the three politicians fled Spain in 2017, following a failed attempt by Catalonia to secede, led by Puigdemont’s government. The former Catalan president has been based mainly in Waterloo, Belgium, since then. Comín is also living in Belgium as is Ponsatí, who also lived in Scotland. Both were ministers under Puigdemont.

The Spanish judiciary has been trying to extradite the trio so that they can go on trial for sedition – and in Puigdemont and Comín’s cases, misuse of public funds – for their roles in the 2017 independence bid. Nine Catalan independence leaders are currently serving prison terms for sedition.

Since becoming MEPs in 2019, extradition procedures against all three have been suspended. The removal of their immunity would see the process resume, although they could attempt to appeal before the European Court of Justice.

Persecution claim

The Catalan MEPs argue that the immunity waiver request should be rejected because it contains procedural irregularities and is based on unsubstantiated charges. They also allege that the entire case is driven by political persecution on the part of the Spanish authorities, accusing the judiciary – in this case the supreme court – of ideological bias.

“We’re not asking MEPs to take sides on how to resolve the Catalan issue,” Ponsatí told The Irish Times. “We’re just asking them to understand that the Spanish judge who is prosecuting us is doing so for political reasons.”

If, as expected, the vote goes against the three Catalan MEPs, Ponsatí warns that this would mean the parliament is “taking the Spanish authoritarian approach to the conflict, which will have negative consequences”.

Esteban González Pons, a Spanish MEP for the European People’s Party, which is expected to vote to lift the immunity, pointed out that his country’s judiciary wants to try them for actions that took place more than a year before they became MEPs. Therefore, their parliamentary status, he says, should not be protected. He also addressed the issue of alleged persecution.

“Puigdemont’s party [Together for Catalonia] has formed part of the Catalan government, it took part in the recent elections, it will probably form part of the next Catalan government,” he told The Irish Times. “You can’t talk about political persecution when the party which the person in question belongs to is governing Catalonia.”

He added: “If the European Parliament decided that in Spain the rule of law does not work, then it would have to proceed to apply article seven to Spain and suspend its European funds.” He does not expect that to happen.

Symbolic victory

If the immunity of Puigdemont, Comín and Ponsatí is lifted then it will be a symbolic victory for the Spanish judiciary. However, a recent precedent suggests that efforts to extradite them are still likely to come to nothing. In January, the Belgian court of appeal ruled against allowing Lluís Puig, a former Catalan minister, to face trial in Spain for misuse of public funds. It found that the Spanish supreme court was not competent to request the international warrant for his arrest.

Puigdemont responded to that news by tweeting that it was “game over” for Spanish attempts to bring him and his colleagues to trial.

The upcoming vote could also have political repercussions in Spain, where the Socialist prime minister Pedro Sánchez has needed the support of the pro-independence Catalan Republican Left in parliament. If, as many expect, Spain’s Socialist MEPs vote to lift the immunity of the Catalan politicians, that could add a new obstacle to stuttering negotiations between Madrid and the Catalan government over the territorial issue.

The Irish Times

The Irish Times online. Latest news including sport, analysis, business, weather and more from the definitive brand of quality news in Ireland.

Related news
Violence against women: Portraits released of all women killed by men in the past year.

Violence against women: Portraits released of all women killed by men in the past year.

Over the last year in the UK, 118 women and girls were killed by men. It's a figure so shocking, that the MP Jess Philips read out the name of every victim in the House of Commons on International Women's Day last month. One illustrator has respon...

Scottish Travellers:  Families torn apart in experiment seek government apology.

Scottish Travellers: Families torn apart in experiment seek government apology.

The Scottish traveller community is demanding an apology from the Scottish government over claims of historical mistreatment dating back to the 1940s. The "Tinker Experiment" relocated families in inadequate housing and took children from homes wh...


CBSN Originals - The Diversity Dilemma

CBSN Originals - The Diversity Dilemma

In the 1960s, affirmative action policies were created to remedy a lack of representation of women and people of color in the workforce and on college campuses. Supporters say it’s an important tool for dismantling structural racism, while critics...


Myanmar protests: Why won't China condemn the military junta's violence? - DW News.

Myanmar protests: Why won't China condemn the military junta's violence? - DW News.

Security forces in Myanmar have reportedly opened fire on medical workers who were taking part in a pro-democracy protest in the city of Mandalay. Hundreds of people have been killed and many more injured since a military coup in February overthre...

Biden 'preparing sanctions against Russia including BANISHING officials from US'.

Biden 'preparing sanctions against Russia including BANISHING officials from US'.

JOE Biden is reportedly preparing sanctions against Russia, including banishing officials from the US, over election meddling and cyber attacks. The president's administration is set to announce a string of measures against Russia on Thursday, acc...


Texas, Missouri sue Biden admin to reinstate 'Remain-in-Mexico' policy.

Texas, Missouri sue Biden admin to reinstate 'Remain-in-Mexico' policy.

Texas AG Ken Paxton tells 'Fox & Friends First' that he believes the states will win in court and discusses the debate over reforming the Supreme Court. #FoxNews FOX News Channel (FNC) is a 24-hour all-encompassing news service delivering breaking...