Ukraine’s motion to disqualify judge in Scythian gold case granted.


Ukraine and world news. Ukrinform brings the latest news, daily news, political news, business news, social news, cultural news, sports news, international news

The Amsterdam Court of Appeal granted Ukraine's motion to disqualify a judge in the Scythian gold case due to confirmation of the presiding judge's link with the lawyers of Crimean museums which could indicate his bias.

As an Ukrinform correspondent reports, the court announced the ruling in writing, without public hearings, today.

"This is a very important victory for us. The ruling will allow the case to be considered by an independent judge and will ensure the adversarial principle in the appellate proceedings. I want to praise the professional and excellent work of our Dutch colleagues. We count on impartial proceedings," lawyer Andriy Karnaukhov, a partner of the Serhiy Kozyakov and Partners law firm, said in a comment to an Ukrinform correspondent in The Hague.

On 2 September 2020, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal began a hearing on the disqualification of a judge in the case of the Scythian gold museum collection. During the hearing, one of the three judges felt ill and the hearing was adjourned. After the break, the presiding judge noted that everything that happened on September 2 before the incident was taken into account.

Ukraine requests to disqualify a judge as additional facts, which could indicate the judge's bias and link with Russia, were revealed.

Earlier, 1 November 2019, a court in The Hague rejected the motion of the Ukrainian side to disqualify a judge of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal who was considering the Scythian gold case. The ruling said that the court did not see any circumstances that would indicate the judge's bias.

The proceedings were, in fact, adjourned pending the ruling on disqualification.

Later, Ukraine filed a second motion to disqualify the judge.

The Ministry of Justice of Ukraine revealed the circumstances that could indicate the bias of the presiding judge. In particular, according to the Ministry of Justice, the presiding judge of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal for several years had represented the interests of the Russian company Promneftstroy in the case against OJSC Yukos Oil Company, i.e. actually defended the interests of the Russian Federation in the case in favor of Promneftstroy. The judge represented Promneftstroy in close cooperation with lawyers representing Crimean museums in the Scythian gold case.

As reported, the collection of Scythian gold had been delivered to the Allard Pearson Museum in Amsterdam as part of the exhibition entitled “Crimea – the Gold and Secrets of the Black Sea” prior to the illegal annexation of Crimea by the Russian Federation.

On 14 December 2016, the Amsterdam District Court ruled that the exhibits of the Crimean museums had to be returned to Ukraine. The judgment was delivered pursuant to the UNESCO convention, according to which the art treasures should be returned to a sovereign state, which provided them for a temporary exhibition.

On 28 March 2017, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal received an appeal against the ruling from the representatives of Crimean museums.

On 11 March 2019, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal started to consider an appeal in the case of the return of the Scythian gold collection to Ukraine.

In July 2019, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal postponed the delivery of a final judgment in the Scythian gold case.

Currently, the Scythian gold collection is kept in the Allard Pearson Museum in Amsterdam.


Новини по темі

MP Dubinsky: Cabinet to re-impose full lockdown in Ukraine from Dec 24.

The lockdown could last from Dec 24 to Jan 15 / Photo from UNIAN, by Denys Priadko The Cabinet of Ministers intends to re-impose a full lockdown in Ukraine from December 24 to January 15. This...

2 11

Ukraine's government mulling over flexible lockdown during New Year's holidays.

The probability of a complete lockdown is 90%.

2 4

Number of new COVID-19 cases in Ukraine on decline

The daily death toll was 120.

1 5

Ukraine reports 213 new COVID-19 cases in armed forces as of Nov 28.

Some 736 servicemen are now isolated(including self-isolation).

4 7

Zelensky, his wife honor memory of 1932-1933 Holodomor victims.

In the 20th century, Ukrainians experienced three famines: 1921-1923, 1932-1933, and the famine of 1946-1947.

4 96

Kyiv reports 1,739 new COVID-19 cases

Kyiv city reported 1,739 new coronavirus cases in the past 24 hours. Fifteen people died, according to Kyiv Mayor Vitali Klitschko.

2 4

Zelensky, his wife honor memory of Holodomor victims.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and First Lady Olena Zelenska honored the memory of victims of the Holodomor in Ukraine, the press service of the head of state has reported.

2 8

Ukraine reports 16,294 new coronavirus cases

As of November 28, Ukraine has reported 709,701 COVID-19 cases, including 16,294 new coronavirus cases confirmed in past 24 hours.

1 1

Daily COVID-19 high beats record third day in row with almost 16,300 cases reported Nov 28.

A total of 709,701 people have been infected in Ukraine since the onset of the pandemic.

Ukraine commemorates Holodomor Memorial Day

On Saturday, November 28, Ukraine commemorates Holodomor Memorial Day.