Appeal court to rule on legitimacy of Netherlands’ coronavirus curfew.

The crisis in the Netherlands over the legitimacy of the coronavirus curfew imposed by the caretaker government last month is expected to be resolved on Friday – when an appeals court rules on whether the overnight restrictions should remain or be abandoned.

With just a month now to a general election, the government’s pandemic strategy was thrown into chaos on Tuesday when a court in The Hague ruled that the curfew had unacceptably curtailed freedom of movement and should end with immediate effect.

The government launched an appeal, and an emergency hearing of the court on Tuesday evening – less than an hour before the curfew was due to start at 9pm – decided that given the national importance of the issue the ban should remain until the substantive question is decided on Friday.

Presiding judge Marie-Anne Tan-de Sonaville said the interests of the state in fighting the pandemic had to “carry more weight” than those of Viruswaarheid (Virus Truth), the anti-lockdown campaign group behind the lawsuit.

Giving evidence, the government’s infectious diseases adviser, Jaap van Dissel, said retaining the curfew was “crucial” in a country where roughly one million people had been infected and some 15,000 had died, and where the position with new variants was “fragile”.

“The overnight curfew, combined with allowing just one person to visit a house in 24 hours, is having a real impact on the infection rate”, he said. “We are talking about exponential growth here, so it is preventing us having to deal with hundreds of new cases every day.”

In advance of that interim decision, acting prime minister Mark Rutte had appealed to the public to continue to support the curfew given the increased risk of infection from new virus strains, although police said they would be “reluctant” to hand out curfew fines until the validity of the law was clear.

To protect against a situation where it loses Friday’s appeal and the legal basis of the curfew is found again to have been faulty, the caretaker government sent new draft legislation to both houses of parliament on Wednesday evening with the aim of anchoring it in law.

Parliament is already in recess in advance of the March 17th election, and will have to be recalled on Thursday morning if the draft legislation is to pass both the lower house and the Senate by Friday evening.

What remains unclear, however, is how MPs and senators will respond to the drama of the past 48 hours – and whether some of those who had reservations about the curfew in January may be emboldened to actually vote against it this time.

The Irish Times

The Irish Times online. Latest news including sport, analysis, business, weather and more from the definitive brand of quality news in Ireland.

https://www.irishtimes.com/

Related news
Live: Sen Warren, progressive Democrats unveil Ultra-Millionaire Tax Act.

Live: Sen Warren, progressive Democrats unveil Ultra-Millionaire Tax Act.

Live: Sen. Warren, progressive Democrats unveil Ultra-Millionaire Tax Act. #FoxNews Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News Channel Live: FOX News Channel (FNC) is a 24-hour all-encompassing news service delivering breakin...

Sahel Child Marriage is Growing Rapidly

Sahel Child Marriage is Growing Rapidly

Why is child marriage rampant in the Sahel and what is being done to stop it? #SAHELCHILDMARRIAGE

COVID:  There is no guarantee for the future of foreign travel.

COVID: There is no guarantee for the future of foreign travel.

Professor Jonathan Van Tam says it's not possible to guarantee the future of foreign travel for the UK. Popular holiday destinations are in varying stages of vaccinating their population leaving the tourist trade in a state of uncertainty. SUBSCRI...

Fact-Checking Trump's CPAC Speech On Election Lies - NBC News NOW.

Fact-Checking Trump's CPAC Speech On Election Lies - NBC News NOW.

NBC News’ Jane Timm fact-checks former President Donald Trump’s CPAC speech, where he attempted to relitigate the 2020 election results and take credit for the Pfizer vaccine. » Subscribe to NBC News: » Watch more NBC video: NBC News Digital is a ...

Cuomo harassment claims should not take focus off nursing homes: NY GOP chair.

Cuomo harassment claims should not take focus off nursing homes: NY GOP chair.

New York State Republican Committee Chair Nicholas Langworthy says nursing home families cannot be forgot no matter how serious the sexual harassment allegations are. Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News Channel Live: F...

Supporters Rally as Hong Kong Activists Are Taken to Court.

Supporters Rally as Hong Kong Activists Are Taken to Court.

Protesters rallied as 47 pro-democracy activists were taken to court on conspiracy charges, Monday, March 1, in Hong Kong. ––––––– READ MORE: Hundreds of demonstrators gathered outside a Hong Kong courthouse Monday in a show of support for 47 pro-...