Bill that overrides UK’s Brexit deal denounced in House of Lords.

The Irish Times

The Irish Times online. Latest news including sport, analysis, business, weather and more from the definitive brand of quality news in Ireland.

The Internal Market Bill, which would allow British ministers to renege on parts of the Brexit withdrawal agreement, has begun its passage through the House of Lords with a series of blistering speeches denouncing it as an assault on the rule of law. Igor Judge, a former chief justice of England and Wales, tabled a “motion of regret” saying the Bill would undermine the rule of law and damage Britain’s reputation.

“When those responsible for making the law – that is, us the parliament, we the lawmakers, who expect people to obey the laws we make – knowingly grant power to the executive to break the law, that incursion is not small. The rule of law is not merely undermined, it is subverted,” he said.

“There is one consequence, and the damage is to our standing in the world. We have no real power now, except soft power – the English language and an understanding that we in this country have a traditional belief in the rule of law and we respect it. We hope that, one day, all the countries in the world that do not have respect for the rule of law will have it. Yet here we are, about to tear it into tatters.”

Breaking the law

The Bill, which passed all its stages in the House of Commons last month, gives ministers the power to break international law by setting aside the Brexit withdrawal agreement to determine unilaterally how parts of the Northern Ireland protocol should be implemented. The withdrawal agreement says a joint committee should decide how to implement the protocol and sets out an arbitration system for resolving disputes.

The government saw off a Conservative backbench rebellion in the Commons by promising MPs a vote before the treaty-breaking clauses are triggered. But former Conservative leader Michael Howard, a leading Brexiteer, said he would vote against the clauses.

“I want the United Kingdom to be an independent sovereign state. However, I want it to be an independent sovereign state that holds its head up high in the world, that keeps its word, that upholds the rule of law and that honours its treaty obligations,” he said.

“I want it to be an independent sovereign state that is a beacon unto the nations. I do not want it to be an independent sovereign state that chooses as one of the first assertions of that sovereignty to break its word, to break the law and to renege on a treaty that it signed barely a year ago.”

‘Advisers out of control’

Former Labour attorney general Charles Falconer said the protocol was a guarantee that the Border would remain open and that without it, closing the Border was the only way to protect the integrity of the EU single market. And he dismissed as “beyond reason” Boris Johnson’s assertion that paperwork accompanying goods moving between Northern Ireland and Great Britain was a threat to the integrity of the United Kingdom.

“He is a prime minister with advisers out of control, looking for political stunts to reinforce the insurgent nature of Brexit, happy to sacrifice the rule of law in the hope of a good culture wars row with Remainers and some screeching headlines, and oblivious to the consequences to the standing of the UK, its long-term relationship with the EU countries and the security and safety of those who live in Ireland,” he said.

“The defenders of the rule of law in government have been forced out, or are too desperate to hold on to the offices into which they have been over-promoted to speak out as they should.”

Related news

US reports record Covid-related death toll

Daily Covid cases hit 200,000 with 2,885 deaths reported on Wednesday

Warning that significant gaps remain in talks between Brexit negotiators.

Johnson still intends on Monday to restore to Internal Market Bill the treaty-breaking clauses that were removed by House of Lords

European and US experts question UK’s vaccine fast-track.

Fauci claims US is proceeding ‘the correct way’ on vaccine while the UK ‘did not do it as carefully’

Whiff of a Brexit fisheries win would bring joy to Johnson.

London Letter: British PM would have little difficulty pushing for the nuclear option

Austria tightens borders and imposes ski restrictions for Christmas.

Stricter measures come amid figures showing record level of 2,431 deaths in one week

Bangladesh begins moving Rohingya families to remote island.

Rights groups call for relocation to be halted on safety concerns and lack of consent from refugees

Explosion at Bristol water plant causes ‘number of casualties’.

Blast at treatment works in Avonmouth believed to have involved chemical tanks

1 13

Four killed in explosion at Bristol water treatment plant.

No ongoing safety concerns after ‘tragic incident’ at Avonmouth facility, say police

Liberian rebel commander in outburst at start of trial for cannibalism, rape.

Alieu Kosiah(45)is also accused of recruiting a 12-year-old as bodyguard during civil war

Swedish woman cleared of imprisoning son for decades.

Authorities to close investigation after finding no evidence man in 40s held against will