Euromaidan Press
News and Opinion from Ukraine and Europe on Military and Political Developments.
It took Red Army ‘a decade’ to subdue Western Ukraine after 1945, Russian specialist on Ukraine warns Kremlin.
Anyone thinking about a Russian invasion of Ukraine today should remember that it took the Red Army at the height of its power at the end of World War II “almost a decade” to pacify Western Ukraine, Viktor Mironenko says. Indeed, an invasion now could lead to “a Russian Vietnam or a new Afghanistan.”
The director of the Center for Ukrainian Research at the Institute of Europe at the Russian Academy of Sciences argues that unfortunately Kremlin policy now is being formulated by people who don’t remember the past and are operating on illusions about the strength of Russian arms and the weakness of Ukraine.
Independence Day Parade in Kyiv, Ukraine. 24 August 2021. Photo: Youtube
Mironenko’s comments came at a roundtable of political and military experts organized by the Rosbalt news agency. Other participants were divided on what the Kremlin is thinking and what may lie ahead. Independent military expert Pavel Felgenhauer argued that “for a large regional war, today everything is ready in Russia.”
But former Duma deputy Ilya Ponomaryev said that he “does not see any logic” in such a move by the Kremlin.” Of course, Moscow wants to manipulate Ukraine; but “after Afghanistan, the Americans cannot allow themselves any foreign policy fiascos” and so Russian leaders know that the US would lead resistance to any Russian invasion.
Photo: mil.gov.ua
The Kremlin’s threatening language has already given Moscow something it very much wants: more Western sanctions on Belarus, something that Vladimir Putin hopes will force Belarus to unite with Russia and give him a new post, head of a union state, to occupy after 2024.
Historian Elena Galkina says the probability of a large war between Russia and Ukraine is about “10 percent.” Moscow may have prepared its military but it hasn’t taken the usual steps to prepare its own population. “The population of Russia is much less prepared for war than it was in 2013.”
[quote]At that time, “Russians believed that half of Ukraine loves us; but now there are no such illusions … [and] today, fewer Russians are aggressively inclined.” Moreover, the costs of occupying Crimea are on everyone’s mind. The costs from an expanded war would certainly be even higher.[/quote]
During the joint military training in Ukraine Rapid Trident. Source: yavoriv-info.com.ua
Sociologist Pavel Kudyukin , however, warns that no one should “overrate the rationality of thinking in the Kremlin,” especially as the center of decision making has shifted from the Presidential Administration to the Russian Security Council where the siloviki are dominant rather than experts on the domestic situation.
And Marina Shapovalova , a writer and economist, says that media hype about the war has been “exclusively in the information field” rather than more broadly as one would expect if Russia were really going to invade. Moscow wants to ensure that Ukraine is never in NATO but doesn’t need to occupy and attempt to pacify it to achieve that end.
Photo: mil.gov.ua
People “both in Russia and Ukraine are afraid of war, although in Ukraine, there is a definite stratum of citizens who are ready to fight for their motherland. In the Russian Federation, there are almost none of these to the extent that no one has attacked their country.”
In a separate comment, Rosbalt commentator Sergey Shelin suggests there is another constraint on Kremlin plans: “Russians do not want to go into battle with Europe on the side of Lukashenka.” They know how the West would react to that, and yet that alliance against Ukraine is precisely what Putin is talking about.
Read More:
- Russia downscales demands to keeping Ukraine, Georgia out of NATO
- US clears Baltic States, Britain to send American-made weapons to Ukraine: media
- What we know about the “light anti-tank weapons” UK started supplying to Ukraine
- Ukrainians ask to personally join NATO, offer private land for NATO base
- Ukraine warns of yet another planned false-flag attack on 19 January
- New Russian aggression in Ukraine will lead not just to sanctions but to a new Iron Curtain, Skobov says
- Russia seeks to maintain its global status by making threats and keeping others off guard, Shevtsova says
You could close this page. Or you could join our community and help us produce more materials like this. We keep our reporting open and accessible to everyone because we believe in the power of free information. This is why our small, cost-effective team depends on the support of readers like you to bring deliver timely news, quality analysis, and on-the-ground reports about Russia's war against Ukraine and Ukraine's struggle to build a democratic society. A little bit goes a long way: for as little as the cost of one cup of coffee a month, you can help build bridges between Ukraine and the rest of the world, plus become a co-creator and vote for topics we should cover next. Become a patron or see other ways to support. Become a Patron!
Russian morning missile strike hits residential building in Dnipro, killing civilians and children.
The missiles also hit the cities of Synelnykove, Pavlohrad, and Kryvyi Rih in Dnipropetrovsk oblast, killing and wounding people there. Air defense shot down nine missiles over the Dnipro Oblast.
Australia extends zero tariffs on Ukrainian goods until 2026.
The Australian government extends tariff relief on Ukrainian goods until 2026 as part of its continued support amidst Russia's invasion.
Ukraine to mass produce “Shmavic,” domestic replacement for Chinese DJI Mavic UAV.
Ukrainian company developed "Shmavic" - domestic analogue of Chinese DJI Mavic drone popular with military. Indigenous drone cheaper, more resilient against EW, coming soon to Ukrainian armed forces. Serial production coming soon.
Russo-Ukrainian war, day 785: Patriot quest for Ukraine picks up steam.
EU, NATO leaders urge Allies not to stockpile their air defense systems but send them to Ukraine; Germany hopes to find seven
Frontline report: Ukraine hammers Russian supply lines as Kupiansk offensive loses steam.
Seizing on a lull in Russia's months-long offensive, Ukrainian forces have launched a series of punishing strikes on ammunition depots, bridges, and command posts, aiming to starve the invaders of vital supplies.
Chris Rufo: This is a tipping point
Manhattan Institute senior fellow Chris Rufo discusses the background of NPR's new CEO Katherine Maher on 'Jesse Watters Primetime.' #foxnews #fox #jessewattersprimetime Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News Channel Live...
Should Conservative MPs share a platform with far-right figures?.
A Treasury minister says the mayor of Brussels was wrong to shut down a conservative conference because it featured far-right figures. Nigel Farage and former home secretary Suella Braverman were among those appearing alongside the Hungarian prime...
Record job losses despite an industry on the rise - what's going on in UK gaming?.
In the last four months alone, more than 8,000 people who make video games have lost their jobs around the world, including in the UK. At the same time, our games industry is growing - so what's going on? Read more: #gaming #jobs #uknews SUBSCRIBE...
Vigil for WPC Yvonne Fletcher as hopes grow for prosecution 40 years after 'callous' murder.
More than a thousand people are expected to head to a London square to celebrate the life of a police officer murdered there exactly 40 years ago. PC Yvonne Fletcher, 25, was shot dead by a bullet fired from inside the Libyan embassy while she was...
Tomi Lahren: 'This shows you how far the Democrat Party has fallen'.
OutKick host Tomi Lahren sounds off on a wave of anti-Israel protesters that flooded U.S. cities in demonstrations across the country and Katie Couric's recent rhetoric about MAGA Republicans. #FoxNews Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Vi...
Labour 'worried about timing' of Rayner investigation ahead of local elections.
Catherine McKinnell, Labour's shadow schools minister, has said she is "worried about the timing" of a police investigation into Angela Rayner ahead of the local elections. She was asked about reports Greater Manchester Police are investigating La...