The Irish Times

The Irish Times online. Latest news including sport, analysis, business, weather and more from the definitive brand of quality news in Ireland.

https://www.irishtimes.com/

Top court appointment leaves Spanish judiciary in the dock.

A contentious vote in Spain’s congress approving an appointment to a top court has paved the way for an end to a long-standing political impasse, while fuelling accusations that the country’s judiciary is not fit for purpose.

On Thursday the Spanish congress voted on whether to appoint four new members of the constitutional court, the country’s highest tribunal. The posts were among many which had long been due for renewal because the two main parties, the governing Socialists and conservative Popular Party (PP), had been unable to agree on replacement candidates.

However, the parties agreed to break the deadlock by approving two candidates presented by each. In the vote, all four received the three-fifths backing of the chamber needed to be appointed, with the support of the leftist Podemos, the junior partner in the governing coalition.

But ahead of the vote, the suitability of the candidates was put under intense scrutiny, particularly one of the PP’s choices, Enrique Arnaldo, due to his political associations and implication in a string of scandals.

It has emerged that Mr Arnaldo received commissions worth nearly €1 million from PP-governed administrations while he was working as a parliamentary jurist – a practice which is prohibited. Mr Arnaldo also featured in audio recordings by the civil guard when they were investigating corruption by the PP in the Madrid region, although he was never charged.

Reports have also suggested that Mr Arnaldo helped the current PP leader, Pablo Casado, to secure the academic credits he lacked in order to secure his law degree in what appears to have been an unfeasibly short period of time.

“I don’t like some of the candidates that the Popular Party has proposed for the constitutional court,” said Socialist prime minister Pedro Sánchez ahead of the vote, before insisting that, despite this, the priority was “to save the agreement to renew our constitutional institutions”.

The Socialists and Podemos hope that the PP will now agree to new appointments on the judicial supervisory body, whose members were due to be replaced three years ago.

However, Mr Sánchez’s fellow Socialist Odón Elorza made clear that voting in favour of the contentious candidate would be difficult for many on the left.

“Arnaldo does not have the exemplary characteristics required,” he said. “Many of us will vote while holding our noses.”

In the end, Mr Elorza was one of a handful of Socialists and members of Podemos who defied party orders by voting against Arnaldo.

‘Anything goes’

The willingness of the Socialists and Podemos to put aside their reservations about such a queried candidate has caused bewilderment among many observers.

“For a long time now, the bi-party thinking has slid towards an anything-goes attitude,” wrote three current and former Podemos MPs in an article criticising the trade-off. They warned that the media had reported in detail “who [Mr Arnaldo] is and what he has done. It has told us what he is capable of and what he will do.”

The right-wing commentator José Antonio Zarzalejos, meanwhile, described the whole affair as “a political crime”.

This episode follows several years during which the image of Spain’s judiciary has been steadily eroded by blatant politicisation. Earlier this year, the National Statistics Institute found that the justice system was the worst-rated public service in Spain, with two-thirds of respondents saying that it was unsatisfactory.

Many have warned that the pragmatism of Thursday’s vote is not just damaging for Spain’s judiciary, but for its democratic self-esteem.

“I don’t understand this idea of voting while holding your nose,” said Joaquim Bosch, spokesman of the Judges for Democracy magistrates’ association. “When the smell is unbearable, the right thing to do is to leave the room without voting…so you can work for the democratic cleansing of institutions.”

Indonesia volcano's violent eruption causes widespread damage.

Indonesia volcano's violent eruption causes widespread damage.

THOUSANDS of people have been forced to flee after a volcano erupted in Indonesia. Smoke and ash were sent spewing 13,000 ft into the air from Mt Ile Lewotolok in Indonesia's East Nusa Tenggara province. The Sun newspaper brings you the latest bre...

Lara Trump: Democratic policies destroying once-great American cities.

Lara Trump: Democratic policies destroying once-great American cities.

'The Big Saturday Show' co-hosts take Biden and Psaki to task for crime and the omicron travel bans. #FoxNews #TheBigSaturdayShow Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News Channel Live: FOX News Channel (FNC) is a 24-hour al...

Pope Francis visits migrants on Greek island of Lesbos - DW News.

Pope Francis visits migrants on Greek island of Lesbos - DW News.

Pope Francis has called Europe's neglect of refugees the "shipwreck of civilization," urging governments to do more to protect them. The Pope is visiting migrants on the Greek island of Lesbos, where more than 2,000 people are living in a camp for...

Sky News Breakfast: UK could see 'more stringent measures' in New Year.

Sky News Breakfast: UK could see 'more stringent measures' in New Year.

On Sky News Breakfast for Sunday, December 5: - Storm Barra set to batter UK as thousands of homes still without power nine days after Storm Arwen. - National investigation launched over six-year-old Arthur Labinjo-Hughes' murder. - NHS planning t...

Christine McGuinness on 'amazing' autism diagnosis

Christine McGuinness on 'amazing' autism diagnosis

Experts say thousands of cases of autism in women could be going undiagnosed. Presenter Melanie Sykes and reality TV star Christine McGuinness are among those who were told as adults they have autism. Why are women prone to such late diagnosis? SU...

Maine police department offers $20,000 signing bonus for new hires amid shortages.

Maine police department offers $20,000 signing bonus for new hires amid shortages.

Brewer police chief Jason Moffitt joined 'Fox & Friends Weekend' to discuss the incentives offered to attract new hires, including a $20,000 signing bonus. #FoxNews Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News Channel Live: FOX...