Social-security payments in occupied territories: ECHR rules in favour of Ukraine.


Ukraine and world news. Ukrinform brings the latest news, daily news, political news, business news, social news, cultural news, sports news, international news

The European Court of Human Rights has ruled in favour of the Government of Ukraine having examined an application over the unlawfulness of the suspension of state budget expenditures on social-security payments in the occupied territories.

“The ECHR ruled in favour of the Government and declared the application No. 33137/16, Kandyba and Others v. Ukraine, inadmissible. Applicants – a group of pensioners living in the temporarily occupied areas of Donetsk and Luhansk regions – went to the administrative courts, challenging the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine No. 595, which approved the "Interim Order for financing budgetary institutions, social-security payments to the population…", Paragraph 2 of which suspended state budget expenditures on social-security payments in the temporarily uncontrolled territory until the control of public authorities is restored over it. The applicants demanded that this provision be declared unlawful and their pension payments be renewed,” Deputy Minister of Justice - Government Commissioner for the European Court of Human Rights Ivan Lishchyna posted on Facebook.

According to him, the administrative courts of three instances partially sustained this claim, declaring Paragraph 2 of the Order invalid on the grounds that the Cabinet of Ministers went beyond its powers by accepting it. However, the courts rejected the requests for renewal of payments as the applicants had addressed improper defendants.

Lishchyna clarified that the applicants addressed many government agencies with a request to renew pension payments on the basis of court decisions but their request was rejected. Later, the applicants filed lawsuits over unlawful inaction of government agencies but the lawsuits were dismissed.

“The applicants complained about a violation of Article 6 of the Convention(right to a fair trial)and Article 1 of the First Protocol(protection of property)in connection with non-enforcement of a court decision in their favour. The ECHR declared the application inadmissible,” the Deputy Minister of Justice said.

“In view of the above, the Court accepts the Government’s arguments that the State could not be reasonably required to enforce a judgment by way of taking actions clearly not envisaged by the court during the adoption of that judgment, and that the applicants could and should, following the ultra vires ruling, have initiated separate proceedings against the appropriate defendants to assert their rights. Moreover, it does not appear from the circumstances of the case, nor is it argued by the applicants that institution of the separate proceedings would constitute additional burden on them, in particular, in view of the complexity of the situation,” Lishchyna quotes the ECHR’s decision.


Главком Британія розраховує у грудні почати вакцинацію населення від коронавірусу. Главком У МОЗ Британії сподіваються, що «десь після Великодня все зможе повернутися до звичного стану»
UA.NEWS Джо Байден офіційно представив склад своєї адміністрації. UA.NEWS Обраний президентом США Джо Байден офіційно назвав, хто займе ключові пости у його адміністрації. Відповідно до повідомлення штабу Байдена, із новим президентом працюватимуть: глава Держдепу –Ентоні Блінкен. Раніше він обіймав посаду заступника глави Держдепу у 2015 –2017 роках при президенті Бараку Обамі, радник з нацбезпеки президента США –Джейк Салліван, директор Національної розвідки –колишній заступник радника президента США […] The post Джо Байден офіційно представив склад своєї адміністрації appeared first on UA.NEWS.
Главком У Дніпровському онлайн-марафоні взяло участь 2000 бігунів із чотирьох континентів. Главком Dnipro Half Marathon Online став заключним з п’яти етапів бігової ліги Ukrainian Majors Running League 2020 Online
УНІАН «Пушкінська тополя» : в Одесі спиляли унікальне дерево-пам'ятник. УНІАН За словами екологів, комунальники отримали дозвіл тільки на підрізування тополі, а не на його повне знищення.
Українська правда Болгарія планує закриття шкіл, ресторанів і ТРЦ для стримування пандемії. Українська правда Болгарія планує закрити школи, ресторани і магазини і заборонити всі спортивні заходи, приватні свята та екскурсії в рамках стримування  сплеску захворюваності коронавірусом.
Related news

First COVID-19 vaccines expected in Ukraine no earlier than May 2021 – media.

The first tranche will include 1.2 million doses.

7 6

Crimea, city of Sevastopol report 282 new coronavirus cases.

Over the past day, 282 new coronavirus cases and seven deaths from COVID-19 were registered in the occupied Autonomous Republic of Crimea and the city of Sevastopol.

5 1

Head of Ukraine's patrol police tests stun gun on himself.

The Taser X2 stun gun automatically records the time, place and duration of every deployment and stores this information, the head of Ukraine's patrol police, Yevhenii Zhukov, has said.


COVID-19 rate in Ukraine currently being restrained.

Weekend quarantine and additional safety measures produce results as statistics show that the projected increase of COVID-19 cases is currently being restrained.

6 1

Interior Ministry explains how to avoid fines for not wearing masks.

All it takes is to take the warning into account.


Russian director refused entry to Ukraine

Border guards of the Kyiv checkpoint have refused entry to Ukraine to a Russian video production director who had previously visited the temporarily occupied territory of Crimea, the Ukrainian State Border Guard Service has told Ukrinform.


Online presentation of book about Crimea held in Croatia.

The Ukrainian Embassy in Croatia held an online presentation of the book entitled “Krim kroz povijest”(“Crimea over the centuries”)in the Croatian language.

4 1

Situation with hospital load under control – health minister.

The relevant funds have been allocated to ensure a sufficient number of beds, the top health official assures.


Over 12,000 people in Kyiv ill with flu and ARVI – city administration.

In the city of Kyiv, 12,231 patients with influenza and acute respiratory infection were registered over the 47th week of 2020(November 16-22), according to the press service of Kyiv City State Administration.


Eight schools, four kindergartens closed in Kyiv due to COVID-19 - Klitschko.

Eight schools and four kindergartens in Kyiv currently remain closed due to COVID-19, according to Kyiv Mayor Vitali Klitschko.