Venice Commission comments on High Council of Justice's urgent reform, criticizes Zelensky's bill on judicial reform – AntAC.


News about recent political developments in Ukraine, key Ukrainian economic news and major current events in the CIS and the rest of the world.

On Friday, October 9, the European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission) approved its opinion on draft law No. 3711 on judicial reform, making a number of critical remarks on the new procedure of the formation of the High Qualification Commission of Judges and noting the importance of immediate resolving of the issue of integrity of the members of the High Council of Justice.

As reported on the website of the Anti-Corruption Action Center (AntAC) last week, the draft law introduced to the Verkhovna Rada by President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky in June was approved in July by the parliamentary committee on legal policy, and later Speaker of Parliament Dmytro Razumkov officially sent the draft law to the Venice Commission for the evaluation. The Venice Commission said in its opinion: "As draft law No. 3711 cannot bring a holistic reform, this opinion cannot have a character of a holistic opinion." The Anti-Corruption Action Center believes that the Venice Commission made it clear that Ukraine needs a comprehensive reform of the judicial governance, and draft law No. 3711 is not such a reform.

According to the opinion of the Venice Commission, the unreformed High Council of Justice should not receive control over the newly created High Qualification Commission of Judges. International experts should be delegated to the High Qualification Commission of Judges competition committee only by recognized world organizations, and in the absence of nominations from international experts. The competition committee should have possibility to evaluate all information about candidates to the High Qualification Commission of Judges, including information with limited access. This means that the High Council of Justice should not influence on this and interfere in the work of the commission and analysis of candidates.

Members of the Venice Commission supported the provisions of the draft law, which abolish the reduction of judges of the Supreme Court. In addition, they spoke about the transfer of judges of the preliminary Supreme Court of Ukraine to the new Supreme Court. These judges must be checked for integrity in the manner prescribed by law.

The Venice Commission's members in their opinion note that "the matter of integrity of the High Council of Justice members is an urgent one and must be dealt without delay" and, referring to the Constitution, refuted the argument about the impossibility of creating a separate independent agency to verify the integrity of the High Council of Justice members. International experts and representatives of the public should be involved in this process. At the same time, the Venice Commission makes a warning that this agency is temporary.

Until such a reform is carried out, experts of the Venice Commission said that the High Council of Justice cannot be given any new powers in the judiciary.

The Verkhovna Rada should take into account the opinion of the Venice Commission in order to maintain cooperation with the West. Draft law No. 3711 needs to be significantly improved before being approved by the Parliament. In addition, in view of the position of the Venice Commission on the issue of the integrity of the High Council of Justice's members, another draft law should be submitted to the Parliament, which will provide for a comprehensive reform of the High Council of Justice.

Related news

It's not just in decision on anti-corruption bodies, but in targeted actions of certain persons to undermine national security – Zelensky.

President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky states that a number of individuals are taking targeted actions to undermine the social contract and to threaten the national security of the country after the Constitutional Court (CC) makes a decision on t...

Zelensky appeals to law enforcement bodies with request to investigate possible impact on Constitutional Court's decision-making.

President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky has asked law enforcement officers to investigate the circumstances that led to the adoption by the Constitutional Court of Ukraine (CC) of a decision on the unconstitutionality of a number of provisions of ...

E-declaration system to operate, bills should be submitted to parliament as urgent – Zelensky.

President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky expects the preparation and submission to the Verkhovna Rada of bills on the resumption of electronic declaration of income of officials in the near future.

Zelensky points out inadmissibility of abolishing NACP's functions.

President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky declares the inadmissibility of abolishing the functions of the National Agency on Corruption Prevention (NACP) in the light of the decision adopted by the Constitutional Court (CC) regarding the activities ...

Rada profile committee receives urgent conclusion of Venice Commission, ODIHR on draft law on all-Ukrainian referendum.

The Verkhovna Rada Committee on the Organization of State Power, Local Self-Government, Regional Development and Urban Planning has officially received an urgent general conclusion of the European Commission "For Democracy through Law" (Venice Com...

Stefanishyna on Constitutional Court's decision: There are forces within the country interested in depriving Ukrainians of visa-free regime, I assure you: they won't succeed.

Deputy Prime Minister for European and Euro-Atlantic Integration Olha Stefanishyna says that the circumstances in which the recent decisions of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine were made raise questions and outrage.

Ambassadors of G7 countries to Ukraine alarmed by efforts to undo anti-corruption reform: Ukraine must not go back to past.

The ambassadors of the G7 countries in Ukraine are alarmed by the efforts to cancel the anti-corruption reforms carried out in the country since 2014.

Rada to quickly react to Constitutional Court's decision to cancel e-declaration – Razumkov.

The Ukrainian parliament will quickly react to the decision of the Constitutional Court to abolish e-declaration and will do everything at the legislative level to ensure that this mechanism continues to work, Chairman of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukr...

UNICEF donates 150 oxygen concentrators for COVID-19 patients to Ukraine.

The United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) has procured and delivered 150 oxygen concentrators to Ukraine for the treatment of critically ill patients with coronavirus (COVID-19) disease, some 125 devices from the newly arrived batch were procure...


Zelensky's poll aimed at mobilizing Servant of People voters, president does not seek to keep promises – experts.

Experts believe that the national poll from President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky, which was conducted on the day of local elections, October 25, was done primarily to mobilize voters of the Servant of the People party in these elections, at the...

By continuing to browse World News (UAZMI), you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and agree to the use of cookies