Trump election lawsuit refused hearing by Wisconsin high court.

U.S. President Donald Trump listens during a ceremony to present the Presidential Medal of Freedom to former football coach Lou Holtz, in the Oval Office of the White House, Thursday, Dec. 3, 2020, in Washington.

U.S. President Donald Trump listens during a ceremony to present the Presidential Medal of Freedom to former football coach Lou Holtz, in the Oval Office of the White House, Thursday, Dec. 3, 2020, in Washington.

AP Photo/Evan Vucci

A split Wisconsin Supreme Court on Thursday refused to hear U.S. President Donald Trump‘s lawsuit attempting to overturn his loss to Democrat Joe Biden in the battleground state, sidestepping a decision on the merits of the claims and instead ruling that the case must first wind its way through lower courts.

The defeat on a 4-3 ruling was the latest in a string of losses for Trump’s post-election lawsuits. Judges in multiple battleground states have rejected his claims of fraud or irregularities. Dissenting conservative justices said the decision would forever “stain” the outcome of the election.

Trump asked the Wisconsin Supreme Court to disqualify more than 221,000 ballots in the state’s two biggest Democratic counties, alleging irregularities in the way absentee ballots were administered. His lawsuit echoed claims that were earlier rejected by election officials in those counties during a recount that barely affected Biden’s winning margin of about 20,700 votes.

Trump’s attorney Jim Troupis said he would immediately file the case in circuit court.

“It was clear from their writings that the court recognizes the seriousness of these issues, and we look forward to taking the next step,” he said in a statement.

In asking the conservative-controlled Wisconsin Supreme Court to take the case directly, Trump had argued that there wasn’t enough time to wage the legal battle by starting with a lower court, given the looming Dec. 14 date when presidential electors cast their votes.

Swing Justice Brian Hagedorn joined three liberal justices in denying the petition without weighing in on Trump’s allegations. Hagedorn said the law was clear that Trump must start his lawsuit in lower courts where factual disputes can be worked out.

“We do well as a judicial body to abide by time-tested judicial norms, even — and maybe especially — in high profile cases,” Hagedorn wrote. “Following this law is not disregarding our duty, as some of my colleagues suggest. It is following the law.”

Trump filed a similar lawsuit in federal court on Wednesday.

Trending Stories

Chief Justice Patience Roggensack, in her dissent, said she would have taken the case and referred it to lower courts for factual findings, which could then be reported back to the Supreme Court for a ruling.

Conservative Justice Rebecca Bradley wrote that the court “forsakes its duty” by not determining whether elections officials complied with the law and the inaction will undermine the public’s confidence in elections.

“While some will either celebrate or decry the court’s inaction based upon the impact on their preferred candidate, the importance of this case transcends the results of this particular election,” she wrote in a dissent joined by Roggensack and Justice Annette Ziegler. “The majority’s failure to act leaves an indelible stain on our most recent election.”

Democratic Gov. Tony Evers praised the decision.

“I was frankly amazed that it was not unanimous,” Evers said.

Trump’s lawsuit challenged procedures that have been in place for years and never been found to be illegal.

He claimed there were thousands of absentee ballots without a written application on file. He argued that the electronic log created when a voter requests a ballot online — the way the vast majority are requested — doesn’t meet the letter of the law.

He also challenged ballots where election clerks filled in missing address information on the certification envelope where the ballot is inserted — a practice that has long been accepted and that the state elections commission told clerks was OK.

Roggensack said the Supreme Court owed it to the public to determine whether that advice was correct, especially for future elections.

“However, doing so does not necessarily lead to striking absentee ballots that were cast by following incorrect WEC advice,” she wrote. “The remedy Petitioners seek may be out of reach for a number of reasons.”

Trump also challenged absentee ballots where voters declared themselves to be “indefinitely confined,” a status that exempts them from having to show photo identification to cast a ballot, and one that was used much more heavily this year due to the pandemic. The Wisconsin Supreme Court in March ruled that it was up to individual voters to determine their status.

Two other lawsuits filed by conservatives are still pending with the Wisconsin Supreme Court seeking to invalidate ballots. In addition to Trump’s federal lawsuit, there is another one in federal court with similar claims from Sidney Powell, a conservative attorney who was removed from Trump’s legal team.

Wisconsin this week certified Biden’s victory, setting the stage for a Democratic slate of electors chosen earlier to cast the state’s 10 electoral votes for him.

© 2020 The Canadian Press

Global News

Breaking news & current latest Canadian news headlines; national weather forecasts & predictions, local news videos, money and financial news; sports stats and scores.

https://globalnews.ca/

Related news
Biden participates in first signing ceremony as president.

Biden participates in first signing ceremony as president.

President Joe Biden participates in a signing ceremony after being sworn in. Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News Channel Live: FOX News Channel (FNC) is a 24-hour all-encompassing news service delivering breaking news ...

Joe Biden gives first speech as president of the United States.

Joe Biden gives first speech as president of the United States.

From Brexit breaking news to HD movie trailers, The Sun newspaper brings you the latest news videos and explainers from the UK and around the world. Become a Sun Subscriber and hit the bell to be the first to know Read The Sun: Like The Sun on Fac...

Analyzing President Biden's formidable global challenges.

Analyzing President Biden's formidable global challenges.

CBS News senior foreign correspondent Mark Phillips joined CBSN to help unpack the foreign challenges newly inaugurated President Joe Biden will face in the White House. CBSN is CBS News’ 24/7 digital streaming news service featuring live, anchore...

Biden Calls For End To 'Uncivil War' Between Republicans And Democrats - NBC News.

Biden Calls For End To 'Uncivil War' Between Republicans And Democrats - NBC News.

President Joe Biden called for an end to the "uncivil war" between Republicans and Democrats in the country with hopes to address the crises facing the country. » Subscribe to NBC News: » Watch more NBC video: NBC News Digital is a collection of i...

With Unity We Can Do Great Things: Biden Urges Americans To Unite In Inauguration Address - NBC News.

With Unity We Can Do Great Things: Biden Urges Americans To Unite In Inauguration Address - NBC News.

During his inauguration address, President Biden urges Americans to come together and says, “with unity we can do great things, important things. We can right wrongs.” » Subscribe to NBC News: » Watch more NBC video: NBC News Digital is a collecti...

Watch Full Speech: President Biden Delivers Inaugural Address - NBC News.

Watch Full Speech: President Biden Delivers Inaugural Address - NBC News.

President Joe Biden delivered his inaugural address with emphasis on a call for unity among Americans to combat the Covid-19 pandemic, work towards economic recovery and end partisan divides. » Subscribe to NBC News: » Watch more NBC video: NBC Ne...