«Social Media Given Rights To Alter Ours» : BJP's Tejasvi Surya On Trump's Ban.

'Social Media Given Rights To Alter Ours': BJP's Tejasvi Surya On Trump's Ban

BJP MP Tejasvi Surya, who is on the parliamentary IT panel, spoke to NDTV Saturday night

New Delhi:

Shortly after Twitter permanently banned Donald Trump from using its services, the outgoing American president has found a pocket of support from unusual quarters - Indian politicians.

All through Saturday functionaries and lawmakers, particularly from the ruling BJP, commented on the rationale behind the ban. One such person was Tejasvi Surya, a BJP MP who heads the party's youth wing and, importantly, is a member of the parliamentary panel on Information Technology.

Social media platforms like Facebook, which have monopolies over content sharing, have been given "rights to alter our rights", Mr Surya told NDTV Saturday night. He said that while the combined user base of Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp - over 80 crore - was more than any news channel, the algorithms used to identify posts violating safe viewing policies "have a bias".

"Twitter may say he has violated certain norms but my concern is all tech giants have such big monopolies of information broadcasting (and) have biased algorithms. Why are we giving them rights to alter our rights? This is the big question democracies must answer," he said.

"Why are we allowing 'intermediaries', which by law must not deal with content, the right to monitor or alter depending on their algorithms? This must be discussed among democracies across world because this poses a serious threat to fair and free elections," Mr Surya added.

Debate on the freedom of expression on social media made headlines around the world this week after Twitter and Facebook announced a permanent ban on President Trump's accounts after concluding he had incited the violence at the Capitol building on Wednesday night.

Facebook cited his "use of our platform to incite violent insurrection against a democratically-elected government." Twitter, which has deleted tweets with allegations about the US election, said it had "permanently suspended the account due to the risk of further incitement of violence".

u6cmrp4o

Outgoing US President Donald Trump's Twitter account has been "permanently suspended"

The bans have invited praise and censure in equally furious measures, with critics of the President welcoming the move and supporters arguing it violates Trump's right to freedom of speech.

In India the debate has focused on allowing hate speech to circulate online. Last month there was controversy after Facebook said there was no cause to act against the Bajrang Dal - a right-wing group with ties to the ruling BJP - despite it being tagged as supporting violence against minorities.

Newsbeep


Also in India Facebook has been accused of not applying hate speech rules uniformly.

Speaking to NDTV Mr Surya said social media platforms were barred from altering, monitoring or changing content because they were viewed as "intermediaries" under Section 79 of the IT Act.

Under such laws, he said, social media platforms did not have authority to remove content. If they want to do so, then they must count themselves as media platforms and be held accountable accordingly. "They must not whimsically (and) based on algorithms remove content," he added.

Mr Surya also referred to Section 69 of the IT Act that outlines provisions for reporting of hate speech or illegal activity to the authorities, who can then ask the platform to take action.

"Unless there is a regulator - a state authority - which can decide if something is hate speech or not, and then take action, this is going to be dangerous... we're letting these platforms decide what is right or wrong," he argued.

Earlier Saturday Mr Surya flagged the Trump ban, calling it a "wake up call for democracies" and saying: "If they can do this to POTUS (President of The United States), they can do this to anyone."

NDTV News

NDTV.com provides latest news from India and the world. Get today’s news headlines from Business, Technology, Bollywood, Cricket, videos, photos, live news coverage and exclusive breaking news from India.

https://www.ndtv.com/

Related news

Sri Lanka Revives Port Deal With India, Japan

Sri Lanka's President Gotabaya Rajapaksa on Wednesday announced the revival of an Indian and Japanese investment project to develop a deep-sea terminal in Colombo harbour, next to a controversial...

NDTV News

US Unveils Plan To Counter China With India's Rise

The Trump administration declassified its strategy to ensure continued dominance over China, which focuses on accelerating India's rise as a counterweight to Beijing and the ability to defend Taiwan...

NDTV News

COVID-19: Councils losing tens of millions of pounds supporting businesses.

COVID-19: Councils losing tens of millions of pounds supporting businesses.

Local authorities are losing tens of millions of pounds supporting struggling business tenants through the pandemic which could have dire and long-lasting consequences for local services, Sky News has found. Of the 272 councils who responded to Sk...

NRA declares bankruptcy, plans move from NYC to Texas.

NRA declares bankruptcy, plans move from NYC to Texas.

The National Rifle Association has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy and plans to reincorporate its headquarters from New York to Texas, Fox News correspondent Lucas Tomlinson reports. Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News...

Coronavirus: Variant concern as vaccine continues to be rolled out.

Coronavirus: Variant concern as vaccine continues to be rolled out.

As fears grow over new COVID variants coming to the UK, it's hoped the government's vaccine programme can keep ahead of the virus. More than 3.5 million people in the UK have been vaccinated against coronavirus in the UK so far - more than the num...

Rep. Johnson on the significance of the newly released Russia probe docs

Rep. Johnson on the significance of the newly released Russia probe docs

Sen. Dusty Johnson, R-SD, discusses the newly released Russia probe documents, a Joe Biden administration and impeachment with Fox News' Griff Jenkins. Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News Video: Watch Fox News Channel Live: FOX News Channel...

Home Secretary under pressure over 400,000 lost police records.

Home Secretary under pressure over 400,000 lost police records.

The Home Secretary is under pressure to explain how 400,000 crime records were accidentally deleted from a national database. Labour leader Sir Kier Starmer said Priti Patel should take responsibility for the error and one senior police officer to...

What will be Trump's legacy? Hear historian's prediction.

What will be Trump's legacy? Hear historian's prediction.

CNN's presidential historian Douglas Brinkley talks with CNN's Don and former White House Communications Director Anthony Scaramucci about what President Trump's legacy will be once he leaves office, and how the riots at the US Capitol have affect...