Dutch lockdown curfew ruled lawful by appeals court.

At the end of a month-long row that has convulsed Dutch politics, an appeals court has found in favour of the caretaker government, ruling that the overnight curfew it introduced in January was legal, proportionate, and necessary to combat the coronavirus pandemic.

The decision overturns a judgment by a lower court last week in favour of anti-lockdown campaign group Viruswaarheid (Virus Truth), which held that the original legislation was flawed because, despite the virus, there was no existential threat in the sense of “a dyke being breached”.

Friday’s ruling in The Hague took the opposite view, however. The judges said the government had made appropriate use of the Extraordinary Powers of Civil Authority Act, specifically intended for use in emergency situations, when it had introduced the curfew.

Instead, the lower court had “set the bar too high” in terms of seeking justification for the curfew.

“The coronavirus pandemic was sufficient cause,” the appeals judges said in a written decision. “The temporary and limited infringement of various fundamental rights, such as the right to freedom of movement, was therefore justified.”

The ruling is a significant win for prime minister Mark Rutte’s outgoing coalition, which is facing a general election in just a fortnight after it was brought down by a long-running child benefits scandal.

Viruswaarheid’s lawyer, Jeroen Pols, said the appeals court decision was “not unexpected” and was further evidence that “human rights are being pushed aside in an unprecedented way”.

It amounted to “the end of the legal order”, he told reporters.

The good news for Mr Rutte is that, despite the importance of the Viruswaarheid case and the fact that his government was forced to rush replacement curfew legislation through parliament in 48 hours last week, anti-lockdown campaigners don’t have enough support to cause an electoral upset.

An I&O survey of attitudes during lockdown showed this week that three days of anti-curfew riots combined with the high profile of the courts process had led to an increase rather than a reduction in support for the curfew, up from seven out of 10 to eight out of 10.

Even so, new infections remain stubbornly high.

Figures for the 24 hours to Thursday morning showed 5,048 new cases, almost 600 above the weekly average, and the biggest daily increase in a month – lending credence to warnings by the public health institute that a third coronavirus wave may be imminent.

The Irish Times

The Irish Times online. Latest news including sport, analysis, business, weather and more from the definitive brand of quality news in Ireland.

https://www.irishtimes.com/

This Morning’s Top Headlines – August 2 - Morning News NOW.

This Morning’s Top Headlines – August 2 - Morning News NOW.

The U.S. surpasses 35 million Covid cases as the delta variant surges, health experts are pushing for more vaccinations among nursing home workers, and Americans no longer need to quarantine when traveling to the U.K. » Subscribe to NBC News: » Wa...

Concha on CDC Director Walensky being the 'wrong COVID-19 messenger'.

Concha on CDC Director Walensky being the 'wrong COVID-19 messenger'.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Director Rochelle Walensky walks back remarks on vaccine mandate. Fox News contributor Joe Concha weighs in on 'Fox & Friends First.' #FoxNews #FoxFriendsFirst Subscribe to Fox News! Watch more Fox News V...

Texas rancher says his county is at the epicenter of a migrant 'invasion'.

Texas rancher says his county is at the epicenter of a migrant 'invasion'.

Brent Smith, a Texas rancher and Kinney County attorney, details damage due to illegal crossings, noting fences have had to be repaired and some ranchers in the area have had to hire private security 'to defend their own property rights.' Subscrib...

ICE To Begin Processing Migrant Families To Relieve Border Station Overcrowding.

ICE To Begin Processing Migrant Families To Relieve Border Station Overcrowding.

In an unprecedented move, ICE is set to begin processing migrant families at the southern border in an attempt to alleviate overcrowding at patrol stations, according to two Homeland Security officials. NBC News justice correspondent Julia Ainsley...

Turkey wildfires - Terrified tourists airlifted & rescued by boats from Brit resorts killing six.

Turkey wildfires - Terrified tourists airlifted & rescued by boats from Brit resorts killing six.

TOURISTS have been airlifted to safety and rescued by boat from popular Brit resorts near Marmaris as wildfires ravage Turkey - killing at least six people. Frantic photos and videos reveal boats and helicopters rescuing people from beaches in the...

Turkey wildfires: Death toll rises with hundreds injured - DW News.

Turkey wildfires: Death toll rises with hundreds injured - DW News.

The death toll from wildfires in Turkey has increased to eight. Firefighting operations continue on the southern and western coast. The latest victims include a Turkish-German couple who were found in a house, local media reported. Hundreds have b...