The Irish Times

The Irish Times online. Latest news including sport, analysis, business, weather and more from the definitive brand of quality news in Ireland.

https://www.irishtimes.com/

Munich church abuse report leaves Pope Benedict exposed.

Irish Catholic priests and bishops will never forget Pope Benedict XVI’s scorching letter from March 2010 saying their action – and inaction – on clerical sexual child abuse had “obscured the light of the Gospel” in Ireland “to a degree that not even centuries of persecution succeeded in doing”.

On Thursday the now retired pope and former Cardinal Ratzinger was confronted with his own action – and inaction – in his four years as archbishop of Munich until 1982, with potentially vast consequences for German Catholics and the fractured global church.

What makes the Munich church abuse report so important is not just that a former pope has to defend his own record as bishop, but that his 82-page written defence is available for all – with knowledge of German – to read.

After expressions of remorse to victims of clerical abuse he attacks investigators for “a remarkable level of bias” that moves “into the realm of subjective evaluation or even cheap propaganda”.

When quizzed on five concrete cases he retreats into legal hairsplitting and denies knowledge or responsibility – or both simultaneously.

He claims a “vague memory” – but no detailed knowledge – of an exhibitionist priest who was given two criminal sentences during Ratzinger’s time as archbishop and moved into a private Catholic school.

No church law

Investigators describe as “divorced from reality” Ratzinger’s claims to have no detailed knowledge of the priest’s two criminal convictions. Similarly objectionable is his claim that, because the priest’s sexualised exhibitionist acts were carried out “in front of” and not “with” victims, there was no church law to use against him.

In a second case, despite indications to the contrary in diocesan files, the former pope denies ever meeting a priest who moved to Munich with a child abuse conviction and was later removed for bathing naked with altar servers.

In another case from the early 1980s, the former pope denies detailed knowledge or involvement in a decision to keep on a priest who had abused and photographed children – and was later convicted.

Case by case, investigators point out how much crossed his desk and the church laws available at the time but not deployed. “His conviction that anything of which he has no memory did not happen seems to the investigators as neither credible nor sound,” they note.

“Emeritus Pope Benedict clearly put church and priestly interests ahead of the interests of injured parties,” the report concludes. “The readiness of Benedict XVI to reflect self-critically on his own role and (at least co-)responsibility . . . is not apparent.”

Останні новини
'Is this the way we're supposed to live?': Blackwell gets emotional covering Buffalo shooting.

'Is this the way we're supposed to live?': Blackwell gets emotional covering Buffalo shooting.

CNN's Victor Blackwell speaks to the family of one of the ten victims killed in the Buffalo, New York, supermaket shooting about the legacy their aunt left behind. #CNN #News

Ukraine War: Russian army pushed back from Kharkiv

Ukraine War: Russian army pushed back from Kharkiv

The battle for Kharkiv may have been won by the Ukrainians but the fighting goes on. Sky News visits the small village of Malaya Rohan in the Kharkiv region which has come under intense shelling. Sky's international affairs editor Dominic Waghorn ...

Russia: Deal reached to evacuate Azovstal's wounded - DW News.

Russia: Deal reached to evacuate Azovstal's wounded - DW News.

The Russian Ministry of Defense said Monday that it had reached an agreement for injured Ukrainian soldiers stuck in the Azovstal steel plant in the besieged southeastern port city of Mariupol to be evacuated to the nearby town of Novoazovsk. The ...

Karine Jean-Pierre 'Represents A Few Firsts' By Holding White House Press Briefing.

Karine Jean-Pierre 'Represents A Few Firsts' By Holding White House Press Briefing.

White House Press Secy. Karine Jean-Pierre discussed how she "represents a few firsts" as the only Black, gay or immigrant woman to hold a press briefing in her new position. » Subscribe to NBC News: » Watch more NBC video: NBC News Digital is a c...

Ukraine Soldier Sings Eurovision Song Amid Shelling.

Ukraine Soldier Sings Eurovision Song Amid Shelling.

Video shows a soldier in an underground bunker singing Ukraine’s Eurovision 2022 entry song, “Stefania,” as sounds of bombing are heard. MORE: Ukraine's winning Eurovision song rings out from the depths of Mariupol's Azovstal steelworks, where wou...

What we know about the alleged gunman in the Buffalo shooting.

What we know about the alleged gunman in the Buffalo shooting.

Payton S. Gendron appears to have been motivated by hate, law enforcement said.

1 1